Thursday, 6 March 2014

Pangloss strikes again

Here we are again

In a recurring ritual the EPO has announced in a press release today "Patent filings at the EPO reach all-time high".

As mentioned in previous posts EPO press releases excite more than inform. A more nuanced picture can be gained by looking to the raw data which can be found here.

So let us analyse some statements in the press release:-

"Patent filings at the EPO grew by 2.8% last year and hit another all-time high,"

Correct, but only if you define patent filings as including PCT applications that will never be subject of any activity in Europe. 

"The EPO granted 66700 European patents, which was 1.6% more than in 2012 (65600) and the highest number ever." 

Correct, and this is to be applauded. 

"Europe continues to be a key market for innovation" 

This is dubious. Looking into the statistics for patent applications [EPO filings and PCT applications entering the regional phase] a slightly different picture is presented:-


Country of Origin 2013 2012 % change
EP Member States 73,420 73,098 0.4%
United States of America 33,834 35,207 -3.9%
Japan 22,555 22,659 -0.5%
China, People's Republic of 4,056 3,732 8.7%
Republic of Korea 6,336 5,719 10.8%
Others 7,668 8,147 -5.9%
Total "rest of world" 74,449 75,464 -1.3%
Overall total 147,869 148,562 -0.5%

The overall total of applications received by the EPO has dropped by half a percent. The total from non-EPO applicants [the rest of the world] has dropped by more than one percent. 

"US with stable increase, Asian countries drivers of growth"

US declining strongly, which matters given its size. Japan down a little, only China and Korea advancing fast - but note the absolute numbers from China and Korea are still relatively low [this may change of course, particularly if the unitary patent comes into effect (see here)].

"In total, filings from Asia accounted for nearly three-quarters of the increase at the EPO in 2013"

It would be more correct to state that it was only the rise in China and Korea that mitigated the catastrophic drop in filings from the rest of the world.

"European industry maintained its patenting activities at the same level as in the previous year, with marked regional differences"

You could say that. 
Country of Origin20132012% change
Germany26,64527,276-2.3%
France9,7549,918-1.7%
Switzerland6,6516,685-0.5%
Netherlands5,8265,06315.1%
United Kingdom4,5674,717-3.2%
Italy3,7043,753-1.3%
Sweden3,6683,5303.9%
other EPO member states12,60512,1563.7%
Total EPO member states73,42073,0980.44%

Larger countries declined, smaller ones grew. Netherlands accounted for most of the growth.

Conclusions

Europe is beginning to fight its way back, but "stagnation" is the best word to describe the innovation landscape, so far as this is represented by patent applications. 

The number of patent applications [European and Euro-PCT] in 2013 was over 2% down on the maximum in 2010.  

The rest of the world is doing very well, but are losing interest in Europe [or at least the EPO - it would be interesting to see what is happening to national filings].

Press reports are not always the best publicity.  

If you have a problem, face it.




Tuesday, 17 December 2013

Will demand for the unitary patent save or sink the EPO?

In a previous post I commented on the lack of growth in patent filings at the European Patent Office. The World Intellectual Property Indicators - 2013 Edition confirms this lack of growth [see Fig. A.1.1.2 at page 46] and the low numbers of patent filings at the EPO compared with other leading offices [see Fig. A.2.1.2 at page 52].


On renewal fees for the unitary patent, I have commented in a first and second post  on what might be a "fair" level.

Assuming that the level of fees is not so high as to be a deterrent, what might be the effect on demand? The following graph plots number of European patents renewed in each country of validation, against total GDP for the countries concerned, and extrapolates this to a market just the size of DE+FR+GB and to a market the size of the unitary patent assuming all participating states (except Poland) sign up. As a sanity check, the number of patents in force in USA, China and Japan is indicated.



As can be seen, this implies a considerable increase in demand. A unitary right covering a market with a GDP of nearly €10 trillion is likely to be highly sought. It is also probable that those who think ahead will start to file more European patents once the unitary patent starts to look a reality.

It would appear that the EPO should be planning now for what they will do if there is a surge in demand. I would expect such a surge to occur once the level of renewal fees is apparent [fear is usually worse than reality].



Saturday, 6 July 2013

So how will it work?

While looking over the background to the unitary patent, and idly wondering what rules the EPO will introduce to manage it, I came across the following little conundrum. The ability of the EPO to act in respect of "special agreements" is governed by Part IX of the EPC.

Article 142(1) of Part IX states:-

Any group of Contracting States, which has provided by a special agreement that a European patent granted for those States has a unitary character throughout their territories, may provide that a European patent may only be granted jointly in respect of all those States.

Article 142(2) of Part IX states:-

Where any group of Contracting States has availed itself of the authorization given in paragraph 1, the provisions of this Part shall apply.

As the Contracting States to the unitary patent have not provided that a European patent may only be granted jointly in respect of those states, they have not availed themselves of the authorisation of paragraph 1, and so it appears Part IX does not apply. As Part IX governs the EPOs role in such special agreements this is a problem.

Accordingly, can the EPO do anything in respect of the unitary patent? It seems the EPC says no, but the regulation is ordering the contracting states to tell the EPO to get on and administer the system.  

All views are welcome.

Tuesday, 25 June 2013

An economic digression - Are the provisions of the UPC compatible with the internal market

The UPC states at s. 24 that Union law shall be a source of law and yet, in its infringement provisions, there appears to be a fundamental inconsistency with the functioning of the internal market which is a core feature of the European Union.

The law of several (all?) Member States concerning indirect infringement provides that there is a double requirement for infringement. Firstly the supply of means relating to an essential element of a patented invention has to be within the national jurisdiction: and secondly the means are supplied to put the invention into effect in that national jurisdiction.

So, a manufacturer who makes and supplies in a country, a product constituting means relating to an essential element of an invention and destined for incorporation into a patented article in that country, will infringe a patent in that country. If the product is  destined for incorporation into a patented article in another country then there is no indirect infringement (not here considering aspects such as joint purpose, that might lead to a finding of direct infringement).

Section 26(1) UPC states (emphasis added):-
A patent shall confer on its proprietor the right to prevent any third party not having the proprietor's consent from supplying or offering to supply, within the territory of the Contracting Member States in which that patent has effect, any person other than a party entitled to exploit the patented invention, with means, relating to an essential element of that invention, for putting it into effect therein, when the third party knows, or should have known, that those means are suitable and intended for putting that invention into effect.
This in effect extends the territorial effect of each national part of a "bundle" patent and of the unitary patent to sale in one Contracting Member State of "means, relating to an essential element..." for putting the invention into effect in another Contracting Member State.

The effect of the generalisation of section 26(1) UPC is thus not simply to provide an enhanced court system, but to extend the acts of infringement that result from a European patent [bundle or unitary] to downstream activities outside the "home" territory of the the supplier of the "means, relating to an essential element..." . 

The effect of this extension on our manufacturer can be appreciated by looking at his potential liability for indirect infringement of a patent in a source country, by making and supplying in the source country, a product incorporated into a patented article in a different destination country. The following two tables show the situation now, and post UPC.

Now
Destination country
Patented UPC country
Patented non-UPC country
Non-patent country
Source country
Patented UPC country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
Patented non-UPC country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
Non-patent country
No – no patent
No – no patent
No – no patent

Under UPC s. 26(1)
Destination country
Patented UPC country
Patented non-UPC country
Non-patent country
Source country
Patented UPC country
Yes if the product is “means relating to an essential element of that invention”
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
Patented non-UPC country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
No – as act of direct infringement only takes place in destination country
Non-patent country
No – no patent
No – no patent
No – no patent

A similar change in effect is seen when one considers the potential liability of a manufacturer for indirect infringement of a patent in a destination country, by making and supplying in a source country, a product incorporated into a patented article in the destination country.
Now
Destination country
Patented UPC country
Patented non-UPC country
Non-patent country
Source country
Patented UPC country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent
Patented non-UPC country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent
Non-patent country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent

Under UPC s. 26(1)
Destination country
Patented UPC country
Patented non-UPC country
Non-patent country
Source country
Patented UPC country
Yes if the product is “means relating to an essential element of that invention”
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent
Patented non-UPC country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent
Non-patent country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – as supply did not take place in destination country
No – no patent

So the effect of the UPC is that whereas at present the manufacturer who only sells product in his home market, only needs to consider patents in force in that country: post UPC he has to consider patents elsewhere in Europe, and his liability depends upon whether his products are subsequently used in a UPC country or a non-UPC country.

This differentiation in liability according to whether or not a downstream user is in a UPC or non-UPC country thus increases fragmentation of the internal market and may be contrary at least to:-
  • Article 26 TFEU concerning free movement of goods;
  • Article 36 TFEU concerning the extent to which industrial property may act as a disguised restriction on trade;
  • Article 20 TEU that only permits enhanced co-operation that will reinforce the integration process.


It should be further noted that this effect bears particularly strongly on SMEs who are most likely to be trading solely in their own country and not considering exports. At present such an enterprise need only look to patents valid in their own country and has no concern as to whether corresponding patents are in existence elsewhere. Post UPC this will change dramatically.

I do not believe that these issues have been considered by the European Parliament, the Commission, the Council, or the Courts in discussing the challenges by Spain and Italy. Perhaps it is not too late to think again?.

Sunday, 16 June 2013

European grant rates

The following graph shows the rate of grant of European patents for applications filed in the indicated year. Does anyone have an explanation?


Tuesday, 4 June 2013

More on Unitary Patent Costs

In a previous post I commented on the appropriate level for renewal fees for the unitary patent by comparing the lifetime renewal cost per million population with costs in UK, France and Germany.

The following graph plots renewal cost per million head of population for:-

  • the potential member states;
  • the figures presented in Commission working papers in 2008 as indicative ranges of cost for the unitary patent;
  • the USA.


















Still not cheap is it?

Friday, 5 April 2013

A non-statistical digression


In a recent article  it has been commented that there is an “unforeseen advantage” to the unitary patent (or to non-opted out European patents) – namely the extension of the scope of contributory infringement from a national level to a (nearly) Europe-wide level.

I don’t think this advantage was unforeseen, I think it was intended: however matters may not be so simple as appears.

Article 26 of the Agreement is not solely applicable to unitary patents as the UPC is not solely applicable to unitary patents (Article 1) and wherever “patent” is referred to both ordinary (“bundle”) and unitary  patents are meant (Article 2(g)).

The effect of the Agreement thus appears to be to broaden national infringement law and expand the scope of contributory infringement - for both unitary patents and “bundle” patent litigated before the UPC  – to cover supply or offer to supply an “essential element” anywhere among the Contracting States where the European patent has effect.

While I think that is a good thing, I am not sure that all of the consequences have been thought through.

EPC Article 64 states that:-
“A European patent shall, subject to the provisions of paragraph 2, confer on its proprietor from the date on which the mention of its grant is published in the European Patent Bulletin, in each Contracting State in respect of which it is granted, the same rights as would be conferred by a national patent granted in that State”.
and
“Any infringement of a European patent shall be dealt with by national law.”

However, a national patent only gives rights in respect of that state and, for example, a UK national patent is not necessarily infringed by supply or offer to supply an essential element in the UK, where the directly infringing act is intended to take place in, say, Germany - even if a national German patent exists.

On a more general level, Article 5 of the Regulation on the unitary patent states that:-
“The acts against which the patent provides protection referred to in paragraph 1 and the applicable limitations shall be those defined by the law applied to European patents with unitary effect in the participating Member State whose national law is applicable to the European patent with unitary effect as an object of property in accordance with Article 7.”

This means that the acts constituting infringement of a unitary patent where the applicable law is that of Germany will be considered under German law even though the effect is throughout the participating states. For another participating state (e.g. UK) the unitary patent (or a European patent litigated through the UPC) will thus not grant the same rights as a national patent (or a European patent litigated through the national courts) and will not be assessed by national law.

This appears contrary to the provisions of Article 64 EPC.

This, to my simplistic mind, means that to provide the breadth of scope for contributory infringement that is envisaged by the UPC, it is necessary to provide identical breadth of scope to national patents, for example, in the UK, by amending Article 60(2) Patents Act to read:-

Subject to the following provisions of this  section, a person (other than the proprietor of the patent) also infringes a patent for an invention if, while the patent is in force and without the consent of the proprietor, he supplies or offers to supply in the United Kingdom a person other than a licensee or other person entitled to work the invention with any of the means, relating to an essential element of the invention, for putting the invention into effect when he knows, or it is obvious to a reasonable person in the circumstances, that those means are suitable for putting, and are intended to put, the invention into effect in the United Kingdom or any country participating in the Agreement of the Unified Patent Court where an equivalent national or European patent is in force .


I dislike using colloquialisms when discussing European matters, but this whole project is a dog’s breakfast that may become proverbial.